Re: Stupid, lazy, unimaginative films
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 8:09 pm
Good catch there about the umbrellas.
..........
"Talking of which, magic invisbility rings that corrupt your personality and can't be melted in a blacksmith's forge make no sense,"
On the contrary, this statement makes no sense to me.
Why is it unfeasible that an invisibility ring could corrupt the wearer? You have to go back to the events of the ring's making - which Im certain Tolkien explains somewhere . Dark magic must have crept into there at some point.
A ring that was made in a forge cannot be later melted back in a forge? Why not? Perhaps after the forging -or during,- a magic rune was set into it fixing this very stipulation.
..........
"Talking of which, magic invisbility rings that corrupt your personality and can't be melted in a blacksmith's forge make no sense,"
On the contrary, this statement makes no sense to me.
Why is it unfeasible that an invisibility ring could corrupt the wearer? You have to go back to the events of the ring's making - which Im certain Tolkien explains somewhere . Dark magic must have crept into there at some point.
A ring that was made in a forge cannot be later melted back in a forge? Why not? Perhaps after the forging -or during,- a magic rune was set into it fixing this very stipulation.