I'm a big fan of András Schiff. I love his Beethoven and Schubert. However, his Bach playing bores me to tears. He seems to play every note with equal weight and consequently robs the music of all life.
I know his argument is that much of this music was written for the harpsicord, which has no dynamic range, but why play it on a modern piano if you don't want to use the full capability of the instrument?