Stu, have you considered the various options for the diaphragms in microphones?
I applaud your enquiring mind but your headline statement says it all. Take an instrument and play it in your lounge (better make it something smallish like a violin or flute) and then go and play it in a large hall, obviously it sounds different. Peter Walker's famous comment "the closest approach to the original sound" was right. All the manufacturers are trying to achieve that, and failing because they are trying to measure their results.
If you listen to studio albums you might get reasonably close to the sound the mastering engineer heard, otherwise, who knows how close an approach you might achieve. Please don't drive yourself mad by trying to achieve perfection, just enjoy the music. Meanwhile, here are some thoughts on Hi-Fi from the 1950s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7fJmmDkvQyc
Everything has a sound
- karatestu
- Posts: 5965
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 4:40 pm
- Location: North Yorkshire
- Has thanked: 1876 times
- Been thanked: 1399 times
Re: Everything has a sound
Thanks for giving it your consideration Geoff. Peter Walkers comment is a very famous one and is of course the ultimate goal. My own instrument (drums) can be made out of many different materials and they do all sound different.Geoff.R.G wrote: ↑Sat Oct 30, 2021 12:38 pm Stu, have you considered the various options for the diaphragms in microphones?
I applaud your enquiring mind but your headline statement says it all. Take an instrument and play it in your lounge (better make it something smallish like a violin or flute) and then go and play it in a large hall, obviously it sounds different. Peter Walker's famous comment "the closest approach to the original sound" was right. All the manufacturers are trying to achieve that, and failing because they are trying to measure their results.
If you listen to studio albums you might get reasonably close to the sound the mastering engineer heard, otherwise, who knows how close an approach you might achieve. Please don't drive yourself mad by trying to achieve perfection, just enjoy the music. Meanwhile, here are some thoughts on Hi-Fi from the 1950s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7fJmmDkvQyc
"Please don't drive yourself mad by trying to achieve perfection, just enjoy the music" - I tried to but I think I am so far up my own backside now that I need rescuing. I wonder about everything and my search for perfection is taking over my life. Thanks for your concern and you are of course correct. Less thinking and talking and more doing is required.
What are your speaker drivers made of ?
DIY FREE ZONE
-
- Posts: 766
- Joined: Sat Jul 01, 2017 12:51 pm
- Location: South yorkshire
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 364 times
- Contact:
Re: Everything has a sound
Stu the best thing to do is to have a control.
I did exactly the same, disappearing up my own arse chasing..... something.
In my csse the control was a pair of quad 11l standmounts, they were nice little speakers, enjoyable, did things i liked, and things i didn't.
I always had something to go back to as a reference.
I built all sorts of speakers and didnt go back to them for a long time. When i did, it gave a reference point, and clarified what the hell it was i was chasing because id completely lost direction.
With the turntables and arms, i have my jbe dd, the airprodigy linear arm and the at33sa cart. Thats my reference, thats what i go back and listen to when i change something on the arm im working on. Thats the reason i havent disappeared up my own arse with the cx arm. I make a change, its either closer to that reference or further away, it tells me which direction to go in
Its like being in a desert without a compass sometimes, you go round in circles ad nauseum until you cant see anything but sand.
Then get very frustrated and give up.
Once you have a reference to go by it becomes a lot less frustrating
I did exactly the same, disappearing up my own arse chasing..... something.
In my csse the control was a pair of quad 11l standmounts, they were nice little speakers, enjoyable, did things i liked, and things i didn't.
I always had something to go back to as a reference.
I built all sorts of speakers and didnt go back to them for a long time. When i did, it gave a reference point, and clarified what the hell it was i was chasing because id completely lost direction.
With the turntables and arms, i have my jbe dd, the airprodigy linear arm and the at33sa cart. Thats my reference, thats what i go back and listen to when i change something on the arm im working on. Thats the reason i havent disappeared up my own arse with the cx arm. I make a change, its either closer to that reference or further away, it tells me which direction to go in
Its like being in a desert without a compass sometimes, you go round in circles ad nauseum until you cant see anything but sand.
Then get very frustrated and give up.
Once you have a reference to go by it becomes a lot less frustrating
Analogue: oracle delphi sme 309, jbe series 3 cx unipivot dv20x2l, roksan xerxes tabriz vm750, jvc ql-y5f rigb at440, jvc ql-y3f vm750, lenco 75, technics sl150
Phono stages: cole lcr, benedict audio hothead
Digital: cyrus cd7, wiim mini x2, topping e30, jds labs el dac 2+
Amplification: nelson pass b1, nelson pass f5
Speakers: 15" fane aperiodic wardrobes
Cans: myryad z40, hifiman sundara + deva, fostex t50rp, sennheiser momentum on ear +over ear, b&w p5 and p7
Phono stages: cole lcr, benedict audio hothead
Digital: cyrus cd7, wiim mini x2, topping e30, jds labs el dac 2+
Amplification: nelson pass b1, nelson pass f5
Speakers: 15" fane aperiodic wardrobes
Cans: myryad z40, hifiman sundara + deva, fostex t50rp, sennheiser momentum on ear +over ear, b&w p5 and p7
-
- Posts: 1569
- Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2016 2:46 pm
- Location: Denham UK
- Has thanked: 133 times
- Been thanked: 483 times
Re: Everything has a sound
I haven't a clue!karatestu wrote: ↑Sat Oct 30, 2021 12:59 pmThanks for giving it your consideration Geoff. Peter Walkers comment is a very famous one and is of course the ultimate goal. My own instrument (drums) can be made out of many different materials and they do all sound different.Geoff.R.G wrote: ↑Sat Oct 30, 2021 12:38 pm Stu, have you considered the various options for the diaphragms in microphones?
I applaud your enquiring mind but your headline statement says it all. Take an instrument and play it in your lounge (better make it something smallish like a violin or flute) and then go and play it in a large hall, obviously it sounds different. Peter Walker's famous comment "the closest approach to the original sound" was right. All the manufacturers are trying to achieve that, and failing because they are trying to measure their results.
If you listen to studio albums you might get reasonably close to the sound the mastering engineer heard, otherwise, who knows how close an approach you might achieve. Please don't drive yourself mad by trying to achieve perfection, just enjoy the music. Meanwhile, here are some thoughts on Hi-Fi from the 1950s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7fJmmDkvQyc
"Please don't drive yourself mad by trying to achieve perfection, just enjoy the music" - I tried to but I think I am so far up my own backside now that I need rescuing. I wonder about everything and my search for perfection is taking over my life. Thanks for your concern and you are of course correct. Less thinking and talking and more doing is required.
What are your speaker drivers made of ?
- Lindsayt
- Posts: 4230
- Joined: Fri Jul 13, 2012 9:06 pm
- Has thanked: 1103 times
- Been thanked: 699 times
Re: Everything has a sound
The impression I've gotten from the speakers featuring kevlar woofers has been that they've not been good at transients. Smoothing them over and taking the edge off them. I don't know if that's inherent to kevlar or is a result of design decisions made by the manufacturer?
The woofers I've liked the sound of best - so far - have been made from paper / doped paper.
The woofers I've liked the sound of best - so far - have been made from paper / doped paper.
- karatestu
- Posts: 5965
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 4:40 pm
- Location: North Yorkshire
- Has thanked: 1876 times
- Been thanked: 1399 times
Re: Everything has a sound
Paper is mentioned as a lot of people's favourite.. Must be something to it.
DIY FREE ZONE
- savvypaul
- Posts: 8672
- Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2016 7:14 pm
- Location: Durham
- Has thanked: 1663 times
- Been thanked: 2994 times
- Contact:
- Lindsayt
- Posts: 4230
- Joined: Fri Jul 13, 2012 9:06 pm
- Has thanked: 1103 times
- Been thanked: 699 times
Re: Everything has a sound
Paper can be doped to variable density. To give more strength / rigidity where it's most required and less mass where it isn't.
I've not heard any Hartley woofers. I'd love to some day. Latex with the surrounds being an integral part of the cone. Instead of being a glued on assembly as per the vast majority of speakers.
I've not heard any Hartley woofers. I'd love to some day. Latex with the surrounds being an integral part of the cone. Instead of being a glued on assembly as per the vast majority of speakers.
-
- Posts: 8586
- Joined: Thu Jul 12, 2012 7:16 am
- Has thanked: 24 times
- Been thanked: 399 times
Re: Everything has a sound
Personally I haven't a clue. I've doped paper, fibre glass and Kevlar and had no problems, with the final sound. What the drivers sound like inherently , don't ask me .
Me thinks nobody in fora land as sufficient simultaneous experience to draw any worthwhile conclusions so I will just use my ears as and when necessary
Me thinks nobody in fora land as sufficient simultaneous experience to draw any worthwhile conclusions so I will just use my ears as and when necessary